diff --git a/conductor/tracks/superpowers_review_20260619/comparison_table.md b/conductor/tracks/superpowers_review_20260619/comparison_table.md index 7e7a11f4..22b53fa6 100644 --- a/conductor/tracks/superpowers_review_20260619/comparison_table.md +++ b/conductor/tracks/superpowers_review_20260619/comparison_table.md @@ -4,23 +4,23 @@ | # | Skill | Primary verdict | Integration tag | Section LOC | Recommended change | Cross-ref | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -| 1 | using-superpowers | | | | | | -| 2 | brainstorming | | | | | | -| 3 | writing-plans | | | | | | -| 4 | test-driven-development | | | | | | -| 5 | verification-before-completion | | | | | | -| 6 | systematic-debugging | | | | | | -| 7 | subagent-driven-development | | | | | | -| 8 | executing-plans | | | | | | -| 9 | dispatching-parallel-agents | | | | | | -| 10 | receiving-code-review | | | | | | -| 11 | requesting-code-review | | | | | | -| 12 | finishing-a-development-branch | | | | | | -| 13 | using-git-worktrees | | | | | | -| 14 | writing-skills | | | | | | -| 15 | mma-orchestrator | | | | | | -| 16 | mma-tier1-orchestrator | | | | | | -| 17 | mma-tier2-tech-lead | | | | | | -| 18 | mma-tier3-worker | | | | | | -| 19 | mma-tier4-qa | | | | | | -| 20 | Dual-Convention + Anything Else | | | | | | \ No newline at end of file +| 1 | using-superpowers | PARITY | INTEGRATED | 41 | none | nagent §3.6, fable §14 | +| 2 | brainstorming | PARTIAL | INTEGRATE-PARTIAL | 65 | add "spec-first is mandatory for any creative work" to Session Start Checklist (HIGH); add "multiple-choice preferred" guidance to spec template (MEDIUM) | nagent §3, fable §3, intent_dsl §1 | +| 3 | writing-plans | PARITY | INTEGRATED | 55 | none | nagent §3, fable §3, intent_dsl §3 | +| 4 | test-driven-development | PARITY | INTEGRATED | 58 | none | nagent §10, fable §13, intent_dsl §6 | +| 5 | verification-before-completion | PARITY | INTEGRATED | 61 | add anti-rationalization table to workflow.md step 9 (MEDIUM); consider promoting to dedicated SKILL.md (LOW) | nagent §10, fable §13, intent_dsl §6 | +| 6 | systematic-debugging | PARITY | INTEGRATED | 71 | add explicit "Question Architecture" rule to AGENTS.md (MEDIUM); consider code_styleguides/debugging.md (LOW) | nagent §10, fable §13, intent_dsl §6 | +| 7 | subagent-driven-development | PARITY | INTEGRATED | 71 | consider tier-4b code quality reviewer (MEDIUM); codify "answer subagent questions" rule (LOW); consider parallel-session execution (LOW) | nagent §5, fable §3, intent_dsl §6 | +| 8 | executing-plans | PARITY | INTEGRATED | 66 | codify "finishing-a-development-branch" check in workflow.md (LOW); consider master-vs-worktree question (LOW) | nagent §5, fable, intent_dsl §6 | +| 9 | dispatching-parallel-agents | PARTIAL | INTEGRATED | 56 | document Meta-Tooling sequential vs Application parallel as deliberate design choice (LOW) | nagent §5, fable §3, intent_dsl §6 | +| 10 | receiving-code-review | PARITY | INTEGRATED | 69 | add explicit "no performative agreement / no thanks" rule to AGENTS.md (LOW) | nagent §3, fable §13, intent_dsl §6 | +| 11 | requesting-code-review | PARITY | INTEGRATED | 60 | (tier-4b code quality reviewer recommended in §7) | nagent §10, fable §13, intent_dsl §6 | +| 12 | finishing-a-development-branch | ARCH-DIFF | INTEGRATED | 68 | document ARCH-DIFF in workflow.md step 9 (LOW) | nagent §5, fable §13, intent_dsl §6 | +| 13 | using-git-worktrees | ARCH-DIFF | INTEGRATED | 60 | none — master-direct is intentional | nagent §5, fable §13, intent_dsl §6 | +| 14 | writing-skills | PARTIAL | INTEGRATE-PARTIAL | 75 | add pressure-scenario testing for each MMA skill (HIGH); rewrite descriptions trigger-focused (MEDIUM); compress to token-budget targets (LOW) | nagent §10, fable §13, intent_dsl §6 | +| 15 | mma-orchestrator | PARITY | INTEGRATED | ~25 | update `gemini` → OpenCode Task tool; fix typos in anti-patterns section (LOW) | n/a (project-specific) | +| 16 | mma-tier1-orchestrator | PARITY | INTEGRATED | ~22 | rewrite description to trigger-focused; expand Limitations (LOW) | n/a (project-specific) | +| 17 | mma-tier2-tech-lead | PARITY | INTEGRATED | ~25 | update Meta-Level Sanity Check commands to scripts/run_tests_batched.py (LOW) | n/a (project-specific) | +| 18 | mma-tier3-worker | PARITY | INTEGRATED | ~12 | add failure_count + Pre-Delegation Checkpoint references (LOW) | n/a (project-specific) | +| 19 | mma-tier4-qa | PARITY | INTEGRATED | ~10 | add "no success claims" rule; reference audit scripts (LOW) | n/a (project-specific) | +| 20 | Dual-Convention + Anything Else | GAP | INTEGRATE-PARTIAL | 66 | adopt conductor convention everywhere; migrate/deprecate 41 superpowers-plugin files (HIGH) | fable §10, nagent §10 | \ No newline at end of file