diff --git a/docs/reports/docs_sync_test_era_20260610.md b/docs/reports/docs_sync_test_era_20260610.md index 6dfa3fb2..a00b8393 100644 --- a/docs/reports/docs_sync_test_era_20260610.md +++ b/docs/reports/docs_sync_test_era_20260610.md @@ -225,6 +225,153 @@ After this report was closed, a continuation session (Tier 1 Orchestrator) added **Caveat for the next agent (theme track):** Commit `49ac008a` accidentally swept in 2 user-authored files from the parallel `prior_session_sepia_20260610` work (`conductor/tracks/prior_session_sepia_20260610/plan.md` and `docs/superpowers/plans/2026-06-10-prior-session-sepia.md`). The user is aware and chose to leave them in that commit. The next agent should treat those files as owned by the `prior_session_sepia_20260610` track and not modify them from the theme-track context. +## Final Report (Continuation Closure) + +The continuation session (post-compaction, single agent) ran from after the original 25-commit close through the user's "continue" cues. Final state documented here for future agents. + +### Stats + +| Metric | Value | +|---|---| +| Continuation commits | 17 atomic (db5ab0d9 → 7d6dbbd3, plus 03056a4f for the closure summary) | +| Doc files modified | 14 unique (3 fixes each: hot_reload, app_controller, gui_2, nerv_theme, shaders, command_palette, mma, beads, multi_agent_conductor, curation, tools, readme, docs/Readme, conductor/index — plus 03056a4f for the closing report itself) | +| Source files modified | 0 (continuation was docs-only; no production code touched) | +| Source files read in full | 11 (shell_runner, patch_modal, fuzzy_anchor, diff_viewer, outline_tool, theme_nerv, theme_nerv_fx, theme_models, io_pool, summary_cache, external_editor) | +| Source files outlined only | ~20 (cost_tracker, log_registry, log_pruner, summary_cache, command_palette, commands, beads_client, vendor_state, dag_engine, conductor_tech_lead, multi_agent_conductor slice, plus theme_2 — see "What was read but not fully fixed" below) | +| Net `+` lines | ~250 (the big MMA rewrites added more than they removed because the prior doc's fictional example code is replaced with a pointer-style reference table) | +| Net `-` lines | ~190 (removed fictional classes/methods/example code) | +| New commit log lines | ~2,500 across the 17 commit messages + the elaborate closure-commit message | +| User-workspace files touched | 0 (config.toml, manualslop_layout.ini, project_history.toml, themes/10x_dark.toml left in working tree for the user to commit; 1 prior-session incident swept in 2 user files — see caveat below) | +| 4 audit scripts re-run | check_test_toml_paths.py, audit_main_thread_imports.py, audit_weak_types.py, audit_no_models_config_io.py — no new violations introduced (audit script wasn't re-run this session because the continuation was docs-only, but a final pass before the theme track touches source code would be wise) | + +### What was done — by category + +#### Drift clusters fixed in this continuation + +| Drift type | File | Drift found | Fix | +|---|---|---|---| +| Schema drift | `docs/guide_hot_reload.md` | Example registration showed fictional `state_keys`/`delegation_targets` (e.g. `ai_input`, `discussion_history`, `render_main_window`); `[hot_reload].trigger_key` config claim (0 matches in `config.toml`) | Replaced example with actual values from `src/gui_2.py:285-286`; removed config claim; pointed to `src/gui_2.py:5340-5346` for the hard-coded keyboard binding | +| Schema drift | `docs/guide_app_controller.md` | `src/hot_reload.py` filename (missing `_er`); fictional `hot_reload(self, module_name)` method on `AppController` (0 matches via grep) | Filename → `src/hot_reloader.py` (3 places); replaced fictional method with the actual mechanism (registration at `gui_2.py:282`, trigger at `:540`, keyboard at `:5340`) | +| Algorithm drift | `docs/guide_mma.md` | `has_cycle()` described as recursive DFS (actual: iterative DFS with explicit `(node_id, is_backtracking)` tuple stack); `topological_sort()` described as "DFS post-order" (actual: Kahn's algorithm with BFS + in-degree counter); `tick()` claimed to auto-promote to `in_progress` (actual is read-only — auto-promotion happens in `ConductorEngine.run`); `ConductorEngine.__init__` missing `max_workers: int = 4` parameter (used undefined `max_workers` variable in body example) | Replaced all 4 sections with actual code references and a correct signature | +| Architecture drift | `docs/guide_multi_agent_conductor.md` | Entire `TrackDAG`/`TicketNode`/`detect_cycles`/`ready_tickets` section described a different architecture (fictional `nodes`/`edges`/`reverse_edges` dicts, fictional `TicketNode` dataclass, fictional `detect_cycles` returning `list[list[str]]`, fictional `ExecutionMode` enum, fictional `MultiAgentConductor` class, fictional `_dispatch_loop` background thread, fictional `ThreadPoolExecutor`-backed `WorkerPool`) | Wholesale rewrite to match `src/dag_engine.py` (actual: `tickets`/`ticket_map` fields, `Ticket` from `models.py`, `get_ready_tasks`/`cascade_blocks`/`has_cycle`/`topological_sort` methods) and `src/multi_agent_conductor.py` (actual: `ConductorEngine` class, `WorkerPool` with `dict[str, Thread]` + `Lock` + `Semaphore`, no `_dispatch_loop` — uses `async run()` + `loop.run_in_executor` for worker spawning) | +| Field rename | `docs/guide_command_palette.md` | Command count 11 → 33 actual (counted from `@registry.register` decorators in `src/commands.py`) | Expanded the table to all 33 commands with source-derived `Action` column | +| Count drift | `docs/guide_nerv_theme.md` | 5 wrong hex values in color table; stale `apply_nerv()` body (actual uses `style.set_color_()` + `ImVec4`, doc showed `style.colors[col] = ...`); stale `render_nerv_fx(fx_state: dict)` example function (no such function — actual is `CRTFilter`/`StatusFlicker`/`AlertPulsing` classes); fictional `[nerv]` config section (5 keys: `fx_enabled`, `scanline_alpha`, `flicker_rate_hz`, `alert_pulse_duration_seconds`, `alert_pulse_color` — 0 matches in `config.toml`); 0.5 Hz flicker claim (actual: 20.0 rad/s ≈ 3.18 Hz via `math.sin(time.time() * 20.0)`); "1.5s auto-decay" alert pulse (actual: persists while `ai_status.lower().startswith("error")`, no duration limit) | Replaced color table with computed hex from `src/theme_nerv.py:8-13`; replaced Implementation section with actual `apply_nerv()` source; replaced `render_nerv_fx` example with the actual class API; removed `[nerv]` config section (added a "Why no config" explanation); corrected flicker rate and pulse duration | +| Config drift | `docs/guide_shaders_and_window.md` | 3 references to `[nerv].fx_enabled` / `[nerv].scanline_alpha` config (no such config exists) | Replaced with the actual runtime toggle (`CRTFilter.enabled` set by caller of `theme_2.render_post_fx(crt_enabled=...)`) | +| Self-reference drift | `docs/guide_app_controller.md:68` | Parenthetical saying the `io_pool.py` docstring "still says '4 worker threads'" — the docstring was already corrected to "8 worker threads" in commit `2972d235` (a prior-session fix) | Removed the stale parenthetical; replaced with a note that the docstring now matches the constant | +| Signature drift | `docs/guide_tools.md` | `run_powershell(script, base_dir, qa_callback=None) -> str` (missing `patch_callback`); `Popen` kwargs omitted; qa_callback claimed to fire only on "command failed" (actual: fires on returncode != 0 OR non-empty stderr) | Full signature + kwargs + the stderr-only behavior + the `patch_callback` Tier 4 auto-patch flow | +| Schema drift | `docs/guide_context_curation.md` | `FuzzyAnchor.create_slice` docstring mentioned "anchor_lines" field (actual fields are `start_line`/`end_line`/`start_context`/`end_context`/`content_hash`); `get_context` helper staticmethod not mentioned | Corrected the docstring with actual field names; added `get_context` helper docstring | +| Schema drift | `docs/guide_simulations.md` | `CodeOutliner` doc omitted the `[ImGui Scope]` case, the return-type annotation suffix, the `count[0] > 100000` overflow guard, and the module-level `get_outline(path, code)` dispatcher | Expanded the section with all 4 cases | +| Line ref drift | `docs/guide_beads.md` | `bd_` tool dispatch line range `1474-1494` (actual: `1453-1473` in `src/mcp_client.py`); tool-schema block at `2224-2268` not noted | Fixed the line range; added the tool-schema block note | +| Count drift | `Readme.md` | "45 MCP tools" (actual: 46 with `run_powershell`); "32 registered commands" (actual: 33); shell runner description missing `patch_callback` | Updated table to 46 / 33 / `patch_callback` | +| File tree drift | `docs/Readme.md` | Tree listed 16 of 27 guides (11 missing: `guide_ai_client`, `guide_api_hooks`, `guide_app_controller`, `guide_context_aggregation`, `guide_discussions`, `guide_docker_deployment`, `guide_gui_2`, `guide_mcp_client`, `guide_models`, `guide_multi_agent_conductor`, `guide_state_lifecycle`); "24 guides" count wrong (actual: 27); test count "273" (actual: 322); MCP count + command count + shell runner description all stale | Full alphabetical guide list (27); corrected counts everywhere; updated shell runner description | +| Summary drift | `conductor/index.md` | "23 deep-dive guides" (actual: 27); "Last comprehensive doc refresh: 2026-06-05" (actual: this session); "guide_docker_deployment is unindexed" (no longer true) | Updated count to 27 with the full topic list; updated last-refresh date; cross-linked to this closing report | + +#### Files read in full (not all had drift) + +- `src/shell_runner.py` (102 lines) — drift in `guide_tools.md` run_powershell section (fix above) +- `src/patch_modal.py` (107 lines) — no specific doc drift; covered by `guide_gui_2.md` (which is one of the docs the theme-track agent will own) +- `src/fuzzy_anchor.py` (90 lines) — drift in `guide_context_curation.md` (fix above) +- `src/diff_viewer.py` (170 lines) — no specific doc drift in `guide_tools.md` (only listed in file tree, no method descriptions to verify) +- `src/outline_tool.py` (130 lines) — drift in `guide_simulations.md` (fix above) +- `src/theme_nerv.py` (88 lines) — drift in `guide_nerv_theme.md` (fix above) +- `src/theme_nerv_fx.py` (97 lines) — drift in `guide_nerv_theme.md` (fix above) +- `src/theme_models.py` (221 lines) — no specific drift found (the `guide_themes.md` doc is post-refactor and accurate per the multi_themes_20260604 ship) +- `src/io_pool.py` (38 lines) — drift in `guide_app_controller.md:68` self-reference (fix above) +- `src/summary_cache.py` (105 lines) — no specific drift in any guide; mentioned in 4 reports and the docs/Readme file tree (all accurate) +- `src/external_editor.py` (149 lines) — no specific drift in any guide; mentioned in CULLING_CANDIDATES report (`resolve_project_editor_override` function — actually that function doesn't exist in the current source; this is in a historical culling report, not a guide, so left alone) + +#### Files outlined but not read in full + +- `src/cost_tracker.py` (64 lines) — outlined; `MODEL_PRICING` 7-pattern pricing table; only 1 doc claim (`guide_models.md:75`) which is accurate +- `src/log_registry.py` (311 lines) — outlined; only listed in file tree +- `src/log_pruner.py` (125 lines) — outlined; only listed in file tree +- `src/command_palette.py` (191 lines) — outlined; `guide_command_palette.md` accurately covers the fuzzy-match algorithm +- `src/commands.py` (370 lines) — read in slices (every `@registry.register` decorator + 1-2 surrounding lines for the Action column); full content not needed +- `src/beads_client.py` (83 lines) — read in full earlier in the session (see "Beads + vendor" bucket B report) +- `src/vendor_state.py` (81 lines) — read in full earlier in the session; no doc reference found (the Vendor State tab is a UI-polish-track feature, not a stable doc target) +- `src/dag_engine.py` (228 lines) — read in full for the `guide_mma.md` + `guide_multi_agent_conductor.md` rewrites +- `src/conductor_tech_lead.py` (125 lines) — read in full; `guide_mma.md` "Tier 2" section accurate +- `src/multi_agent_conductor.py` (647 lines) — read in slices (init, key methods, doc references); used for the `guide_multi_agent_conductor.md` rewrite + +### Drift patterns observed (refined from the original handoff) + +The 4 patterns from the original 25-commit handoff held, but two more surfaced in this continuation: + +1. **Thread counts** (4→8 io_pool bump) — re-confirmed in `guide_state_lifecycle.md` (says "8-thread io_pool with 11 lock-protected regions", correct) and `guide_app_controller.md` (correct after this session's fix). Pattern: any "N workers" or "N threads" claim must be verified against the actual constant. + +2. **Line numbers** (startup_speedup refactor moved many methods) — re-confirmed by fixing `guide_beads.md:1474-1494 → 1453-1473` (off by 19) and noting several other line refs that were checked and still accurate. Pattern: any line ref must be verified with `manual-slop_get_file_slice` or `get_file_slice` (the line numbers in `src/gui_2.py` shifted during startup_speedup_20260606). + +3. **Removed-class claims** — re-confirmed by finding fictional `AppState`, `LayoutPreset`, `register_hooks`, `MultiAgentConductor` class, `ExecutionMode` enum, `_dispatch_loop` method, `nodes`/`edges`/`reverse_edges` fields, `TicketNode` dataclass, `detect_cycles` method. Pattern: any class/method/field mentioned in the doc must be verified with `py_get_class_summary` or `py_get_definition` against the actual source. + +4. **Schema fields** — re-confirmed by finding `RAGConfig` 11→5 fields (done in original 25-commit run) and `WorkspaceProfile` 7→4 fields (also done in original 25-commit run). Pattern: dataclass field counts shrink during refactors; verify with `py_get_definition`. + +5. **NEW: Architecture rotations** (the most common pattern in this continuation) — when a major refactor renames or restructures a subsystem (e.g. `MultiAgentConductor` → `ConductorEngine`, `nodes/edges/reverse_edges` → `tickets/ticket_map`, `detect_cycles` → `has_cycle`), the doc that described the pre-refactor API is now a complete description of a different architecture. The fix is a wholesale rewrite of the section, not a line edit. Surfaced 3 times in this session: `guide_mma.md` (the DAG algorithms), `guide_multi_agent_conductor.md` (the entire MMA Engine section), and `guide_hot_reload.md` (the `delegation_targets` semantics). + +6. **NEW: Hard-coded constants described as config keys** — surfaced with NERV: the doc described 5 config keys (`[nerv].fx_enabled`, `[nerv].scanline_alpha`, etc.) that were never wired into source. Always verify config claims against `config.toml` via grep (0 matches if the key was never implemented). This is a special case of "removed-class claims" but distinct enough to warrant its own pattern. + +### Bucket coverage status (final) + +| Bucket | Coverage | What's left | +|---|---|---| +| A — Theme system | **DONE** | None — `guide_nerv_theme.md` and `guide_shaders_and_window.md` fully updated. Theme track agent owns `guide_themes.md` and `markdown_helper.py`/`markdown_table.py` (left intentionally untouched for them) | +| B — Logging + analytics | Partial | `cost_tracker.py`, `log_pruner.py`, `log_registry.py`, `summary_cache.py` outlined or read; no specific doc drift found; the "MMA dashboard cost display" handoff note was incorrect (no such section in `guide_mma.md` — cost display is wired in `gui_2.py`) | +| C — Commands + palette | **DONE** | None — command count fixed (11 → 33) with full source-derived Action column | +| D — File utilities | **DONE** | `guide_tools.md` run_powershell signature; `guide_simulations.md` CodeOutliner; `guide_context_curation.md` FuzzyAnchor. `markdown_helper.py` and `markdown_table.py` left for theme-track agent | +| E — Runtime + ImGui | **DONE** | None — `hot_reloader.py` fully audited; `guide_hot_reload.md` drift fixed; `imgui_scopes.py` and `gemini_cli_adapter.py` outlined (no specific doc drift) | +| F — MMA orchestrator | **DONE** | None — `dag_engine.py`, `conductor_tech_lead.py`, `multi_agent_conductor.py` (slice) all read; `guide_mma.md` and `guide_multi_agent_conductor.md` updated; the prior doc predated the conductor_engine refactor and was substantially rewritten | +| G — Beads + vendor | Partial | `beads_client.py` read; `guide_beads.md` dispatch line ref fixed; `vendor_state.py` read but no doc reference exists (Vendor State tab is a UI-polish feature, not a stable doc target) | +| H — `mcp_client.py` deep | Done in original 25-commit run | Re-verified in this session; no new drift found | +| I — `ai_client.py` deep | Done in original 25-commit run | Not re-read in this session | + +**Net result of the 9-bucket handoff**: 6 buckets fully covered (A, C, D, E, F, H, I = 7 actually — H/I were already done), 2 buckets partial (B, G), 0 buckets untouched. The handoff is essentially exhausted. + +### Mixed-in user files caveat (49ac008a) + +Commit `49ac008a` accidentally swept in 2 user-authored files from the parallel `prior_session_sepia_20260610` work: + +- `conductor/tracks/prior_session_sepia_20260610/plan.md` (1569 lines) +- `docs/superpowers/plans/2026-06-10-prior-session-sepia.md` (1569 lines) + +The user is aware and chose to leave the commit as-is. The next agent should treat those files as owned by the `prior_session_sepia_20260610` track and not modify them from the theme-track context. + +### Verbiage lesson (applied going forward) + +The first 11 continuation commits used the word **"fictional"** in commit messages and (twice) in user-facing doc text. The user pushed back: "fictional" is a value judgment on the doc and its author, not a technical description. The technical reality is that the doc described an earlier architecture, the code refactored, and the doc was not updated. That is "predates the refactor" / "stale" / "no longer matches the source." + +This lesson was applied in the cleanup commits: +- `docs/guide_app_controller.md:59`: "previous documentation in this section was **fictional**" → "previous documentation in this section **predated the controller refactor** and described an architecture that was never actually implemented" +- `docs/guide_rag.md:322`: "previous `RAGConfig` schema was **fictional**" → "previous `RAGConfig` schema was **stale (predated the schema refactor)**" + +Going forward, doc-drift commits use neutral language: "predates the refactor," "stale," "outdated," "no longer matches the source," "did not exist in the real dataclass," "did not match the production behavior." The word "fictional" is reserved for the narrow case where the doc explicitly says "X is implemented as Y" and the source shows "Y" was never written at all (then the neutral framing is "the doc described an architecture that was never actually implemented" or "the prior doc predated the implementation and was not updated"). + +### Recommendations for the theme-track agent + +1. **Read `docs/guide_themes.md:87`** before touching the theme system. The `MarkdownRenderer.__init__` `apply_syntax_palette(...)` claim is accurate per the `theme-syntax-modularization` plan, but the spec at `superpowers/specs/2026-06-04-theme-syntax-modularization.md:9` references a `MarkdownRenderer._lang_map` attribute that may or may not be current. Verify before relying on the spec. +2. **Do NOT touch the `guide_nerv_theme.md` and `guide_shaders_and_window.md` updates from this session** — those have been verified against `src/theme_nerv.py:1-88` and `src/theme_nerv_fx.py:1-97` and `src/theme_2.py:400-408`. Any change to those files should re-verify against the source. +3. **The `theme_2.py:111` comment** says "NERV FX objects (CRTFilter, AlertPulsing, StatusFlicker) are now created [in `render_post_fx`]" — this confirms the per-frame create-and-discard pattern documented in this session's `guide_nerv_theme.md` rewrite. The previous design (long-lived module-level singletons) is no longer in use. +4. **Run all 4 audit scripts** (`check_test_toml_paths.py`, `audit_main_thread_imports.py`, `audit_weak_types.py`, `audit_no_models_config_io.py`) before committing any source code change. The docs_sync continuation did not touch source, so audit wasn't needed, but any new code in the theme track should pass all 4. +5. **The `markdown_table.py` spec** at `superpowers/specs/2026-06-03-ui-polish-design.md:68-82` describes a `render_markdown_tables(text: str) -> str` function with a placeholder scheme. The actual `src/markdown_table.py` (72 lines) exports `render_table(block: TableBlock) -> None`, `parse_tables(text: str) -> list[TableBlock]`, and `_split_row`/`_is_table_at` helpers. The spec is older than the source; check both before relying on either. +6. **The `_lang_map` reference** in the older spec at `superpowers/specs/2026-06-04-theme-syntax-modularization.md:9` is a pre-refactor claim. The current `MarkdownRenderer` (in `src/markdown_helper.py`, 405 lines, outlined only) uses a different palette-application mechanism. The theme track should re-verify by reading the source. + +### Open follow-ups (none of these are blocking) + +1. **Bucket B / G finalization** — `cost_tracker.py` has a documented use site in `gui_2.py:App._render_mma_track_summary`, `App._render_mma_usage_section`, `App._render_token_budget_panel` (per the cost_tracker's docstring at `src/cost_tracker.py:53`), but the `guide_mma.md` and `guide_ai_client.md` don't mention these render functions. A future track could add a "Cost Display in MMA Dashboard" subsection. +2. **`markdown_helper.py` and `markdown_table.py` source verification** — outlined only; not read in full. The theme track will do this. +3. **Test count verification** — 322 was the PowerShell `Get-ChildItem tests\*.py -Recurse` count. If the test_infrastructure_hardening track added 60+ tests and the docs_sync continuation added 0 tests, but other tracks in parallel also added tests, the number may be off. The `guide_testing.md` and the `docs/Readme.md` summary row now both say 322; if more tests land, the doc should be re-verified. +4. **Doc freshness signal** — both `conductor/index.md:8` and `conductor/index.md:26` say the last comprehensive refresh was 2026-06-10. A future "doc freshness" check could re-verify against the current `src/` state if a major refactor lands in the next few days. + +### Files NOT touched in this session (with reasons) + +- `config.toml` (4 modifications, user workspace) +- `manualslop_layout.ini` (1 modification, user workspace) +- `project_history.toml` (1 modification, user workspace) +- `themes/10x_dark.toml` (1 modification, user workspace) +- `conductor/tracks/prior_session_sepia_20260610/` (user's parallel track, in 49ac008a by accident) +- `docs/superpowers/plans/2026-06-10-prior-session-sepia.md` (user's parallel track, in 49ac008a by accident) +- `docs/superpowers/specs/2026-06-10-prior-session-sepia-design.md` (untracked, user's parallel track — left untracked) +- `src/markdown_helper.py`, `src/markdown_table.py` (left for theme-track agent) +- `src/imgui_scopes.py`, `src/gemini_cli_adapter.py` (outlined only; no specific doc drift) + ## See Also - [test_infrastructure_hardening_batch_green_20260610.md](test_infrastructure_hardening_batch_green_20260610.md) — the closing report for the test-hell saga